Australians are demanding answers after a staggering judicial miscalculation put a convicted terrorist back on our streets, only for him to be arrested in dawn counter terrorism raids over an alleged ISIS inspired car bomb plot.
Back in December 2023, NSW Supreme Court Justice Hament Dhanji, the first Judge of Indian descent appointed to the NSW Supreme Court bench, made the astonishing decision to throw out the Commonwealth’s bid for a 12 month Extended Supervision Order against convicted terrorist Nowroz Amin.
Despite Amin serving his full five year, four month sentence in Supermax, twice being denied parole, and repeatedly refusing prison deradicalisation programs, Justice Dhanji bought Amin’s story that he had abandoned extremism.

Ruling that there was only a “bare possibility” Amin was lying about his deradicalisation and claiming “the evidence suggests the defendant no longer holds extremist views,” Justice Dhanji let him walk free without supervision – and even ordered taxpayers to foot Amin’s legal bill.
Fast forward to yesterday morning: heavily armed counter terrorism police were forced to swoop on properties across 10 Sydney suburbs, arresting the 35 year old Amin in Ingleburn.
He is now back behind bars, charged with possessing violent extremist material linked to ISIS and researching how to build a vehicle borne improvised explosive device.
Had counter terrorism police not intercepted him in time, Sydney could have been staring down the barrel of another catastrophic, mass casualty terror attack.
This raises an urgent question for every law abiding Australian: Where is the accountability for the bench?
When a judge ignores glaring red flags, dismisses warnings from counter terrorism detectives, and releases a high risk extremist into the community, only for that exact individual to be charged with plotting a car bomb, should judges face real consequences for catastrophic errors of judgment?
Why do everyday Australians have to bear the lethal risk while out of touch judges remain completely untouchable?