In my earlier article, The Captaincy Is About More Than Winning: Integrity Must Come First, I asked whether an Australian captain who knew about the Cape Town sandpaper plot, and then publicly claimed otherwise, could remain in the job. That question just got harder to set aside.
Cameron Bancroft, one of the three players sanctioned in 2018, has now said it wasn’t just Smith, Warner and himself who knew about the sandpaper. In his words: “It was the whole team.” He says he withheld details during the original investigation to protect others, and that he is “angry and betrayed”. That directly contradicts Pat Cummins, who has maintained that he knew nothing.
The claim didn’t come out of nowhere. It follows the release of Usman Khawaja’s autobiography Sabr, which includes fresh claims that the entire team knew sandpaper was being used. Bancroft’s statement was reportedly published hours after Cricket Australia announced that players would get a chance to discuss the incident without fear of further sanctions.
That announcement matters too. Cricket Australia has set up a confidential independent forum but will not re-open the investigation. CEO Todd Greenberg confirmed that only eight of the 11 players in the Cape Town Test were interviewed in 2018. David Warner has since called for an “open and independent inquiry” and raised concerns that the forum has no completion date.
Cummins’ position has not changed. CA’s interim chair David Boon argued that his account has been consistent: what he said after the 2018 Test, some years later, and again last week. Consistency is not proof of accuracy, though, and it is not proof of the opposite either.
This is where the distinction I drew in my first article matters. Being unaware of wrongdoing, knowing and failing to act, and knowingly misleading the public are three different things. Bancroft’s claim is an allegation about what the team knew. It is not evidence about what any one player knew, and it does not establish that Cummins misled anyone. Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon have previously denied publicly that they were aware of the plan.
What has changed is the weight of testimony. A man who admits he did the act, and says he stayed quiet to protect his teammates, has now put his version on the record. Khawaja and Warner back the broader claim, and Cricket Australia has conceded that its original process didn’t hear from everyone.
The forum is a chance to settle this, but only if people take part and the findings are made public. Greenberg has said that is the intention, but it isn’t locked in. If the forum is private, or players decline to attend, the questions around the captaincy will linger.
My view hasn’t changed from the original piece. Cummins deserves a fair hearing, and no one should be judged on allegations alone. But if credible evidence emerges that he knew and said otherwise, his position becomes untenable. Until then, the best thing for Australian cricket is a process open and thorough enough that no one has to take anyone’s word for it.
A new statement released by Pat Cummins manager Neil Maxwell.
“Pat’s position hasn’t changed in eight years. He’s been consistent and adamant from day one”
“There is nothing he hasn’t answered & that includes in response to what Cam has now said”