Every summer, Port Fairy fills with visitors, and the road from Warrnambool fills with their cars. For the people who live in between, in Koroit, Illowa and the farming country around them, the lack of a train is felt all year round. It is a fair question whether passenger rail could return over this short stretch, and a fairer one to ask what that would honestly take.
The railway to Port Fairy is part of the region’s story. Its last train ran in September 1977, when the section beyond Warrnambool was closed because there were too few passengers. V/Line services now end at Warrnambool, and the corridor beyond has had a second life.
The population of Port Fairy is approximately 3,700 people but this swells for the summer season to 12,000 to 14,000 people. By comparison, Ararat receives 5 x V/Line passenger trains each way per day (Monday to Friday) and also has the overland available. Victoria has grown substantially since 1977 as have the regional centres and public use of the passenger rail network has outstripped capacity highlighting just how popular travelling by trains around Victoria has become.
It is tempting to think most of the work is done, because the formation still exists and, as locals point out, there are few major road crossings. But the rails were lifted after the last train, and the corridor is now the 37 km Port Fairy to Warrnambool Rail Trail. It opened in 2012 for about $2.2 million and is estimated to draw around 100,000 visitors a year, although many recognise the true numbers of people using rail trails are inflated by those who advocate for them.
Near Warrnambool it runs along road reserve rather than the old alignment, so getting trains into town would take work of its own. And the distance is not as short as it sounds: the old line loops through Koroit, making this a 37 km railway, not a short hop.
Reinstating it would mean new track, signalling and stations, plus level crossings built to modern safety standards, because even a quiet crossing needs proper protection. No public cost estimate appears to have been completed. Demand is the other question. The line closed for want of passengers, and the towns along it are small, so a service would have to be justified by summer tourism, by commuters from Koroit and the surrounding district, and by the value of linking Port Fairy to the Melbourne line.
Then there is the trail itself, which is no obstacle to be brushed aside. Communities more than ever are calling for return of their passenger services, Communities would rather have relaible rail services than a seldom used rail trail which sounded good at the time.
The Warrnambool Line Upgrade was completed in 2024, and six-carriage trains are due to start running later this year. The Coalition has promised six-car trains too if it wins the November state election. Neither commitment has excluded an extension to Port Fairy.
None of this means the idea should be dropped. A full return of V/Line services is possible in principle, though it would take capital to complete. Jess Wilson has run her election campaign at least in part to returning investment to regional centres, this could be one such project available for consideration. Heritage and tourist services could also use the extension during times of the year popular with those visiting the coast.
The people between Warrnambool and Port Fairy, and the visitors who arrive each summer, deserve a a better service than a V/Line bus and associated slogan. The sensible next step is a state-funded feasibility study: what it would cost, who would use it, and what the community is prepared to trade. Until that work is done, trains to Port Fairy remain a worthy question rather than a plan.